Articles
Home Affairs in court for ‘blocking’ identity documents
No ID, no life. This is the fate of many children in South Africa who are victims of their parent’s IDs being “blocked” by the Department of Home Affairs.
Their births are never registered or are registered very late; their parents cannot access child support and other grants; they are excluded from or discriminated against at school; they struggle to access health care and immunisation programmes. Without an identity number they are “invisible” to the state.
These are the submissions of the Children’s Institute at the University of Cape Town, represented by the Centre for Child Law, admitted as an amicus curiae in a case to be argued this week in the Pretoria High Court.
In the matter, Lawyers For Human Rights (LHR) is representing more than 100 people who have fallen victim to an “arbitrary” ID blocking practice by Home Affairs (DHA).
In December 2020, the Minister of Home Affairs revealed in Parliament that DHA was dealing with more than 800,000 blocked ID cases, involving alleged duplicates and what it claims are “fraudulent” IDs.
In September 2023, DHA admitted in its answering affidavit that ‘these cases have become more and more as the years went by”, and that in May 2023, the Minister had agreed to remove blocks from 1.4-million people’s IDs. However, approximately 700,000 IDs remained blocked at end of July 2023.
LHR said in the past five years it had assisted more than 500 people with blocked IDs, the majority of them poor, black South Africans. None were aware of their blocked IDs until they attempted to access a service and discovered the issue “quite literally by surprise”.
None received prior notice of DHA’s intention to block their IDs,or investigate their status, nor were written reasons for the decision provided.
In the application, which is being opposed by the Minister and the department, LHR asks for an order declaring ID blocking unlawful and unconstitutional, an order that all IDs be unblocked, and and order that the department follows “just administrative action”.
The harmful impact of this on children is addressed in an affidavit by senior researcher Paula Proudlock at the Children’s Institute, using case studies of children (and their parents) which the institute is currently assisting.
She said a study by UNICEF estimated that in 2017 two million eligible children had been excluded from accessing social grants in South Africa. The absence of a birth certificate or an ID card for the caregiver was the primary reason for this.
“Our own analysis of survey data revealed that children without birth certificates are more likely to be excluded from other government services, including social grants, health care, immunisation and education.”
Proudlock said the institute represented three classes of children: those who had no birth certificates, because their parent’s ID was blocked; those who had birth certificates but could not apply for ID cards when they turned 16, because their parent’s ID was blocked; and those between the ages of 16 and 18 who had IDs but whose IDs were blocked when their parent’s ID was blocked.
The majority fell into the first category; without a birth certificate the children had no access to their right to a name and nationality.
“Ultimately, they suffer significantly when they have no say or choice in the matter. It is a violation of their rights to participate in decisions that affect their rights and to have their best interests considered.”
Proudlock said the majority were poor, black and African, and were “invisible to the DHA”.
‘Like someone who does not exist’
In a supporting affidavit, NZ (name withheld to protect the identity of her children) said she is a South African citizen who gave birth to triplets in July 2019 at a Durban hospital. They were born premature. When she went to DHA offices in Umgeni Road to register their births, she was advised that her ID was a “duplicate” ` that she was sharing it with another person. The official told her that she was “like someone who does not exist”.
She was advised to fill in another application for an ID and submit her fingerprints and photos and told she would receive a call when the investigation was completed, but it could take at least six months.
In the subsequent months, the bank ATM swallowed the SASSA card (she was receiving a child support grant for her elder daughter), and, with the discharge from hospital of the triplets imminent, a friend raised concerns with a doctor about how she was going to cope financially.
The doctor organised colleagues to donate money, clothes and nappies.
But her situation remained dire. She was evicted from her home in January 2020. In February, a dietician at the hospital took up her cause with the DHA. But there was little progress and, at one point, a social worker advised her to give up the babies for adoption.
In November, the institute managed to arrange child support grants for the children from SASSA and, finally, the triplets’ births were registered when they were two years old.
“It is unlikely her case would have been resolved if she had not gone to the media and if the hospital dietician had not been advocating on her behalf by emailing DHA and reporting the matter to the public protector,” Proudlock said.
Blocked for over a decade by Home Affairs error
Citing another example, Proudlock said a 12-year-old girl, living with her paternal grandmother in the Eastern Cape, still had no birth certificate because the ID of her mother, who Is a South African citizen, had been blocked for over a decade for being a duplicate.
The “duplication” was caused by a DHA error when two young people, both with the same name, applied for the IDs at similar times in 2002.
“We have been able to ascertain that the East London DHA office issued IDs to both, but swapped their dates of birth by mistake. One applied for a correction and was issued with a new ID with her correct date of birth. At this stage, a ‘shared ID profile’ appears to have been created. And DHA now only has one FN (name withheld) on their system,” she said.
Proudlock said the child had been sent to the Eastern Cape because, without a birth certificate, her mother could not enrol her at a school in Cape Town.
It was easier to get admission to rural schools without a birth certificate.
“She has thus grown up separated from her mother, father and younger siblings”.
No proper recourse
Regarding children who have birth certificates, but cannot get an ID because their parent’s ID is blocked, Proudlock said many of these children could not write matric, receive their matric results or register for tertiary education.
They cannot open bank accounts, register their cellphone or apply for NSFAS funding.
“Their chances of becoming employable are significantly reduced. And some become depressed and suicidal, with no hope,” she said.
Children who have IDs which get blocked at the same time as those of their parents suffer the same consequences. In addition, they cannot apply for learner’s licences or driver’s licences, apply for social grants for themselves, or register any babies born to them.
“The cycle of harm is perpetuated … many mothers we have assisted only became aware that their ID was blocked when they attempted to give notice of the child’s birth. They received no prior notice.
“They are given unclear oral explanations and no written reasons. There are no prescribed forms to lodge an inquiry or start an investigation,” Proudlock said.
“In most cases, our clients were victims of identity fraud or DHA clerical errors and yet were summarily stripped of their citizenship and identity without notice or explanation and are then required to bear the onerous burden of re-proving their birth, identity and citizenship. If they were orphaned or abandoned when they were a child, which many of the mothers we are assisting were, then it is impossible to produce the proof DHA demands.”
Supporting the relief sought by LHR, the institute said it also wanted statistics on the number of children adversely affected by ID blocking, as the numbers DHA has provided are for blocked adults and do not account for the thousands of children whose lives are also on hold.
The hearing has been set down for 20 and 21 September.
V.4986
Govt responds to passport rushGovt responds to passport rush
GOVERNMENT has extended operating hours at the Civil Registry Department after its offices were flooded with desperate Zimbabweans applying for passports. Snaking queues have emerged at the Civil Registry Department offices countrywide after Finance minister Mthuli Ncube proposed an increase in passport fees beginning next month. Ncube said he would increase fees for an ordinary passport from US$120 to US$200, while an emergency travel document will be priced at US$300 up from US$200. V.5108
Click here for full article
06. Dec. 2023 BBC NewsCouples `devastated` by migration visa rule changes
Scientists Josie and Joan Ferrer Obiol says their dream of returning to the UK has been turned upside down Couples planning a new life in the UK have been left heartbroken by changes restricting who can apply to live here. From April 2024, British citizens or people already settled in the UK will need to show they earn £38,700 before their overseas partner can live here with them - a sharp jump from the current threshold of £18,600. They also still need to show they are in a marriage or civil partnership when they apply for a family visa, intend to be within six months, or that they have been living together for at least two years. V.5109
Click here for full article
06. Dec. 2023 SABCSouth Africa is first African country added to Saudi Arabia’s e-visa
A Saudi man checks the flight timings at the King Khalid International Airport, after Saudi authorities lifted the travel ban on its citizens after fourteen months due to coronavirus disease (COVID-19) restrictions, in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, May 16, 2021. South Africa has become the first African country that Saudi Arabia has added to its e-visa system. This simplifies the process for South Africans seeking e-visas for travel to Saudi Arabia. V.5110
Click here for full article
05. Dec. 2023 France24UK announces limits on regular migration as it tries to turn polls around
London (AFP) Britain`s embattled Conservative government unveiled a raft of measures Monday aimed at cracking down on record levels of migration a key battleground in a general election expected next year. Home Secretary James Cleverly unveiled proposals to cut regular migration. The UK announced it would raise the minimum salary threshold for a skilled worker visa and prevent overseas health and social care staff from bringing family dependents to Britain. V.5106
Click here for full article
05. Dec. 2023 News24Foreign parents: Constitutional Court declares parts of Immigration Act unconstitutional
The Constitutional Court has ruled that parts of the Immigration Act are unconstitutional. • The Constitutional Court has declared sections of the Immigration Act invalid and unconstitutional as they discriminate against foreign divorced and separated parents. • According to the act, a foreigner on a spousal visa must leave the country when their relationship with a South African ends, even if they have children together. • The court gave Parliament 24 months to make the necessary amendments to the act, so it is consistent with the Constitution. V.5107
Click here for full article
04. Dec. 2023 Pro Bono & Human RightsThe right to apply for asylum in South Africa
The Constitutional Court (CC) recently handed down an important judgment which speaks to the right to apply for asylum in South Africa. Over the past several years, we have seen more and more anti-foreign national rhetoric in the public domain, with even high-ranking government officials contributing to the narrative that foreign nationals are the cause of many of South Africa’s issues. This has resulted in a continuingly shrinking safe space for foreign nationals who intend on seeking refuge in the country. Given our current socio-political climate, this judgment comes at a critical time where the rights of vulnerable people must be protected, in line with our international and domestic obligations. At a glance. V.5100
Click here for full article
04. Dec. 2023 News24Sting operation prevents 443 Zimbabwean children being trafficked into South Africa, says home affairs
42 buses from Zimbabwe were stopped and searched at the Beitbridge border post. • On Saturday evening, 42 buses from Zimbabwe were stopped and searched at the Beitbridge border post. • According to home affairs, 443 unaccompanied minor children were found on the buses. • It is alleged that the children were being trafficked into South Africa. The Border Management Authority (BMA) at the Beitbridge border post has stopped more than 40 buses carrying about 440 unaccompanied children, who were allegedly being trafficked into South Africa. V.5101
Click here for full article
04. Dec. 2023 News24Sting operation prevents 443 Zimbabwean children being trafficked into South Africa, says home affairs
42 buses from Zimbabwe were stopped and searched at the Beitbridge border post. • On Saturday evening, 42 buses from Zimbabwe were stopped and searched at the Beitbridge border post. • According to home affairs, 443 unaccompanied minor children were found on the buses. • It is alleged that the children were being trafficked into South Africa. The Border Management Authority (BMA) at the Beitbridge border post has stopped more than 40 buses carrying about 440 unaccompanied children, who were allegedly being trafficked into South Africa. V.5102
Click here for full article
04. Dec. 2023 News24Sting operation prevents 443 Zimbabwean children being trafficked into South Africa, says home affairs
42 buses from Zimbabwe were stopped and searched at the Beitbridge border post. • On Saturday evening, 42 buses from Zimbabwe were stopped and searched at the Beitbridge border post. • According to home affairs, 443 unaccompanied minor children were found on the buses. • It is alleged that the children were being trafficked into South Africa. V.5103
Click here for full article
04. Dec. 2023 Immigration TorontoExploring Canada`s rental cost, Most and least expensive cities
Each year, Canada attracts numerous international students who enter the country by obtaining study visas and permits. These students are required to adhere to specific conditions throughout their academic journey. One crucial aspect that international students often consider is Canada’s rental cost. One major issue affecting international students’ entire experience in Canada is the expense of renting. It is crucial that they comprehend and budget for the costs related to housing while they are studying in the nation. Furthermore, international students looking for accommodation in Canada may make better decisions if they are aware of the rental circumstances and market trends. V.5104
Click here for full article
04. Dec. 2023 SA MigrationProtection of asylum seekers and of children facing lifelong statelessness highlighted in two significant South African decisions, case note extracts
Asylum seekers face huge obstacles trying to reach a country that can offer them refuge. One of their greatest challenges is the risk of detention on arrival because their entry to the country is unauthorised. Now a landmark judgment reinforces protection of asylum seekers and respect for their right to seek and enjoy asylum even if they are in the country unlawfully, while the state’s responsibility in cases of statelessness, another major problem for refugees, is considered in a second decision. Asylum seekers face numerous obstacles as they strive to reach a country that can offer them refuge. One of the greatest challenges they encounter is the risk of detention upon their arrival. This is because they often enter countries through unauthorized means like using false documentation, entering without proper authorization, and relying on smugglers to assist them. V.5105
Click here for full article
29. Nov. 2023 Global MigrationLatest updates in global immigration
This week, the Global Immigration team at Smith Stone Walters would like to highlight the following recent updates from Australia, Denmark, Hong Kong, Israel, the Netherlands, Sweden, Switzerland and the United States. Australia: Start date set for permanent residence changes The Department of Home Affairs has set a start date of 25 November 2023 (subject to the approval of regulation changes) for its previously announced changes to the employer-sponsored permanent residence programme. From that date, all Temporary Skill Shortage (TSS) (subclass 482) visa holders will be able to access permanent residence via the Temporary Residence Transition (TRT) stream of the Employer Nominated Scheme (ENS) (subclass 186) visa. V.5098
Click here for full article
29. Nov. 2023 Associated Australian PressHome affairs boss Pezzullo sacked after leaked texts
Mike Pezzullo has been sacked as head of the home affairs department after a code of conduct breach finding. Mr Pezzullo was stood down after leaked messages revealed the secretary repeatedly inserted himself into the political process. The governor-general in council terminated his appointment on Monday. The texts revealed he lobbied for his department and pushed his personal views, in breach of public service standards, across a five-year period. It is not suggested the messages show corrupt or illegal conduct. Home Affairs Minister Clare O`Neil referred the matter to the Australian Public Service Commissioner after concerns were raised following media reporting of the messages. V.5099
Click here for full article
28. Nov. 2023 Associated Australian PressHome affairs boss Pezzullo sacked after leaked texts
Mike Pezzullo has been sacked as head of the home affairs department after a code of conduct breach finding. Mr Pezzullo was stood down after leaked messages revealed the secretary repeatedly inserted himself into the political process. The governor-general in council terminated his appointment on Monday. The texts revealed he lobbied for his department and pushed his personal views, in breach of public service standards, across a five-year period. It is not suggested the messages show corrupt or illegal conduct. V.5097
Click here for full article
27. Nov. 2023 Digital JourneyIndia Provides Enhanced Online Visa Access to Citizens of South Africa, Switzerland, New Zealand, and Bulgaria
India, a country renowned for its diverse landscapes and rich cultural heritage, is pleased to announce that citizens of South Africa, New Zealand, Switzerland, and Bulgaria can now enter the nation without a visa. This progressive step demonstrates India`s commitment to forging international connections, boosting tourism, and expediting the visa application process for travelers from these nations. Indian history, culture, and scenic landscape have long drawn travelers from all over the world. Travelers from these countries are invited to experience India`s famous sites, varied customs, and stunning scenery thanks to the increased visa access. V.5096
Click here for full article
23. Nov. 2023 The SowetanSham doctor case leads police to fake identity syndicate within home affairs
The NPA is waitng on Interpol results on Kingsley Chele`s identity verification. More than 370 fraudulent documents issued by public servants An investigation into the two identity documents belonging to bogus doctor Kingsley Leeto Chele led to police cracking an alleged syndicate involving home affairs officials who are accused of selling documents to illegal immigrants. A source close to the investigations has revealed how the syndicate had issued over 370 fraudulent documents and had been charging more than R2,000 per applicant. V.5092
Click here for full article
23. Nov. 2023 News24How much does a tourist visa cost for the UK, USA, Australia, and most Schengen Zone countries?
The visa application process in South Africa includes a load of paperwork, appointments made way in advance and a heavy fee. Getty Images • South Africa has one of the world`s `weakest` passports. • This means we often need to buy pricey visas to visit foreign countries. • Here`s how much you`ll pay for several popular tourist visas and how long they take to process. V.5093
Click here for full article
23. Nov. 2023 iolCape Town woman allowed to emigrate with her two children to live in Dubai with US fiancé
relocate to Dubai with her children where they will be living with her American fiancé. The woman was married and got divorced from the father of her children in January 2016. The children were eight and three when their parents divorced. At the time of the divorce, both parties lived in Durban. In March 2019, the woman relocated with the children to Cape Town. The father would visit the children and sometimes they would visit him. In 2020, she started dating GJ, an American citizen. She said for almost two years, they have been living together with GJ as a family. V.5094
Click here for full article
23. Nov. 2023 BusinesstechReverse emigration twist for South Africa
Although many wealthy South Africans are packing their bags for the UK, new migration data shows that the inverse is also true. The latest Wealth Migration Report 2023 from Henley & Partners and New World Wealth shows that around 400 High Net-Worth Individuals (HNWIs) those with a net worth of over US$1 million (roughly R18 million) emigrated out of South Africa in 2022 with a further 500 leaving the country in 2023. The UK is an emigration hotspot for South Africans with the 2021 UK census noting that over 215,000 South Africans live on the island. V.5095
Click here for full article
22. Nov. 2023 Human Rights WatchSouth Africa Mulls Major Immigration Overhaul
Migration may be an increasingly contentious issue in South Africa, but that does not justify taking an axe to refugee rights and chipping away at the country’s commitments under the United Nations’ 1951 Refugee Convention, as the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) recently proposed alongside other immigration reforms. V.5088
