Articles
Blocking people from jobs based on criminal records in South Africa, what bosses should know
Recently settled case in the Labour Court demonstrated that excluding a job applicant because of their criminal record is only lawful when the requirements of that job explicitly outline and justify the need for a clean criminal record.
However, legal experts say that the court’s decision ultimately delinked trust and honesty from the inherent requirements of a job, which was “concerning.”
ENS Africa’s Nils Braatvedt, Kim Vova, and Lutho Zono examined the background, outcome, and subsequent analysis of the recent court ruling in O’Connor v LexisNexis.
The experts said that “this decision emphasises the risk of automatically excluding applicants from employment based on an inherent trait such as a criminal record.”
Background
O’Connor [first name omitted] applied for a senior data expert role at LexisNexis. As part of the recruitment process, the company required applicants to declare whether they had ever been criminally charged.
Acknowledging his past theft conviction from 2001 had been expunged, O’Connor was initially offered a job by LexisNexis based on the outcome of a background check.
LexisNexis withdrew their job offer following the check, which unveiled six theft charges, one fraud charge, and two charges of obstructing justice.
Aggrieved at this decision and after unsuccessfully attempting to settle the dispute at the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA), O’Connor approached the Labour Court.
He alleged that LexisNexis unfairly discriminated against him based on his past criminal convictions, basing the argument on a section of the Employment Equity Act that prohibits “unfair discrimination” in any employment policy or practice.
Court ruling
In considering whether O’Connor had been unfairly discriminated against, the court assessed whether the differentiation based on a criminal record was ” arbitrary.”
The court found that having a criminal record is an inherent attribute that is connected to how a person is viewed in society. Additionally, the court said that the idea behind criminal justice in South Africa is that once a criminal have paid their debt to society, that person must be allowed back into society.
“Accordingly, the Labour Court found that differentiation on the basis of a criminal record is an arbitrary ground as contemplated in section 6 of the EEA,” said Braatvedt, Vova, and Zono.
Additionally, the court had to ascertain whether discrimination was justifiable on the basis that it was an inherent requirement of the job for O’Connor to have a clean criminal record.
The court reached the conclusion that the position did “not require a significant amount of trust and honesty”, where the possibility of O’Connor’s rehabilitation should be completely disregarded.
It, therefore, found that LexisNexis did not demonstrate that a clean criminal record was an inherent requirement for the role and ordered that it would be just and equitable for LexisNexis to employ Mr O’Connor in the role.
Legal Commentary
“What is perhaps concerning about the Court’s decision is the delinking of trust and honesty from the inherent requirements of a job,” said the ENS experts.
The ultimate decision was influenced by LexisNexis’ inadequate response to the claim’s core issues, with the court suggesting a different outcome had they engaged with the allegations.
However, the legal experts said that “the decision seems to contradict the common law principle that there is a reciprocal duty of good faith which obliges an employee to perform work in a trustworthy and honest manner �` indeed, trust underpins the employment relationship.”
“Insofar as the Court found that Mr O’Connor’s role did not require a significant amount of trust, there is either trust, or there is not �` an employer cannot be expected to tolerate a degree of untrustworthiness or dishonesty regardless of how clerical or geographically distinct an employee’s work may be,” they added.
The ENS experts said that, in their view, the enquiry should have started with the assumption that trust and honesty are essential for any job, and the key question should have rather been how a 20-year-old criminal conviction affects an employer’s trust in the applicant.
Things to note going forward
“Employers should bear in mind that excluding an applicant because of their criminal record is only lawful when the inherent requirements of the job legitimately require a clean criminal record,” said the experts.
A noteworthy part of this case involves O’Connor’s upfront disclosure of his criminal history, showing “a degree of honesty” despite potential employment consequences.
“Employees who refuse to disclose their criminal convictions when they have been asked to do so could be guilty of misconduct,” said Braatvedt, Vova, and Zono.
V.5347
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
27. Aug. 2024 Sowetan Live
Court rules in favour of traditional wife and nullifies civil marriage
Hilda Sedinjane turned to the Limpopo High Court in Polokwane for an order that she be recognised as the true wife of deceased Seabela Malatji. The parties concluded a customary marriage in 1988 as evidenced by a lobola certificate and four children were born of the marriage. V.5574
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
26. Aug. 2024 Cape Times
Outdated systems expose Home Affairs
Home Affairs Minister Leon Schreiber on Tuesday said his department should urgently embrace technology, or South Africas national security would be under threat. Schreiber said the problems in the issuance of fraudulent visas pointed the department towards a solution that lay in embracing digital transformation in all its facets and across the department. V.5571
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
26. Aug. 2024 Polity
Home Affairs committee wants inspectorate unit strengthened to track foreign nationals
The Portfolio Committee on Home Affairs pointed out that while the deportation of 95 Libyan nationals has been effected, the need to strengthen the inspectorate unit of the department is necessary and called for an enhanced monitoring tool to track foreign nationals in the country. Earlier this week, the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) concluded its preparations to deport the 95 Libyan nationals, after they were arrested in White River, Mpumalanga, last month. V.5572
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
23. Aug. 2024 Sowetan Live
Two more people caught over IDs-for-sale scam
Duo`s arrests follow that of home affairs office cleaner Office cleaner Rhandzu Chauke with family and lawyer outside the Pretoria magistrates court, this after appearing on the charge of theft of home affairs stamp. The arrest of two undocumented Mozambican nationals in connection with the selling of fake IDs has lifted a lid on an alleged documents-for-cash scheme believed to be happening at the home affairs office in Centurion. V.5562
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
23. Aug. 2024 TIMES TRAVEL
How to apply for Greece tourist visa: A step-by-step guide
Synopsis Travelers planning to visit Greece need a Schengen visa. The process includes scheduling an appointment, filling out an application form, submitting required documents, attending an interview, and waiting for processing. Greece is a gorgeous European nation noted for its iconic island destinations such as Santorini and Mykonos, among others. Those planning a trip to Greece, applying for a tourist visa is a must. Because Greece is a European nation, youll need to apply for a Schenegen visa. However its an easy process if you are aware of all the necessary steps carefully. V.5564
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
23. Aug. 2024 Daad
Austria Job Seeker VISA With Family VISA Application Process
Ever dreamt of swapping your daily grind for a life filled with stunning mountain views, world-class music, and enough pastries to make your heart sing? Well, Austria is ready to roll out the red carpet for you! One of the key pathways to entering Austria as a skilled worker is through the Austrian Job Seeker Visa (Category D). V.5566
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
23. Aug. 2024 Daily Maverick
Deadly Marabastad stampede sheds light on struggles of undocumented migrants in SA
Police are investigating a stampede that took place at the Home Affairs offices in Marabastad in Pretoria in which one person died and 20 more were injured. The story of Chidimma Vanessa Adetshina and how she became a contestant in the Miss South Africa pageant has cast notions of nationality and access to documentation for foreign nationals living in South Africa into the spotlight. V.5568
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
23. Aug. 2024 DW
New Zealand: Emigration soars amid economic woes
New Zealand`s population of 5.3 million grew by just 0.1% (7,000) in the second quarter of 2024 as the number of those leaving the country reached well over 100,000 in the first half of the year, official statistics showed on Monday. The practical stagnation in population growth comes despite record numbers of arrivals in recent years driven largely by the island nation`s reputation for high living and working standards and as a haven of security in an increasingly troubled world. V.5569
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
23. Aug. 2024 DW
New Zealand: Emigration soars amid economic woes
New Zealand`s population of 5.3 million grew by just 0.1% (7,000) in the second quarter of 2024 as the number of those leaving the country reached well over 100,000 in the first half of the year, official statistics showed on Monday. The practical stagnation in population growth comes despite record numbers of arrivals in recent years driven largely by the island nation`s reputation for high living and working standards and as a haven of security in an increasingly troubled world. V.5570
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
21. Aug. 2024 IOL
Visa backlog: Portfolio committee welcomes overtime approval for Home Affairs officials
The Portfolio Committee on Public Service and Administration has welcomed the approval of overtime for Home Affairs officials to reduce the visa backlog. This comes after Minister of Public Service and Administration, Inkosi Mzamo Buthelezi and his department granted the overtime request from Homes Affairs Minister Leon Schreiber for the next three months to meet target and reduce the backlog. V.5560
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
20. Aug. 2024 News 24
While Schreiber wants to bring dignity to Home Affairs, xenophobia rears its head in budget debate
Several parties represented in Parliament blamed undocumented migrants for crime and draining social services during the debate on the Department of Home Affairs` budget. Claims undocumented migrants are disproportionately responsible for crime or are depleting South African taxes without contributing, have previously been debunked. New Home Affairs Minister Leon Schreiber said he wanted to bring dignity back to the department`s work. V.5555
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
20. Aug. 2024 Groundup
Judge slams law firm for misleading court with `cut-and-paste` applications targeting refugees
Gauteng Judge President Dunstan Mlambo has slammed a firm of attorneys and an advocate for `cut-and-paste` work in cases involving refugees. He ordered them to pay out of their own pockets for costs awarded in these cases. Manamela MA Attorneys was running a `cottage industry`, preying on vulnerable refugees, Mlambo said. A firm of attorneys and an advocate have been ordered to pay the costs, from their own pockets, of six `cut-and-paste` applications involving refugees seeking asylum, GroundUp reports. V.5556
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
20. Aug. 2024 My Broadband
How to get your new Smart ID at a bank
South Africans looking to upgrade their green ID booklet to a smart ID card can book an appointment to do so using the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) eHomeAffairs platform. Moreover, the system allows applicants to book appointments at DHA-supported bank branches across the country, meaning they never have to step foot in a Home Affairs office or face the associated queues. V.5557
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
20. Aug. 2024 SowetanLive
How stolen home affairs stamp led to cleaner`s bust
A year and four months after a stamp used to authenticate documents was stolen at a home affairs office, a 24-year-old man presented a birth certificate bearing the same stamp to apply for an ID. The certificate, however, was found to be fake and was produced four months after the stamp was stolen. V.5559
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
19. Aug. 2024 SABC 3
Spaza shop owners cry foul regarding Gauteng government funding
Local entrepreneurs and spaza shop owners have lashed out at the Gauteng Department of Economic Development for failing to deliver on their promises which were part of the R100 million Kasi Mnotho Fund. The fund was aimed at offering strategic loans and empowering businesses to secure trading stock, equipment, machinery and working capital. This initiative was promised to business owners in an attempt to foster entrepreneurship and propel economic growth in Gautengs townships. V.5552
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
19. Aug. 2024 IOL
Identity fraud rockets in SA
Identity fraud is on the increase in South Africa, with the latest fraud statistics recording a 400% surge in impersonation fraud from April 2023 to April 2024. Fraud statistics from the Southern African Fraud Prevention Service (SAFPS) have also revealed that impersonation fraud increased by a staggering 356% from April 2022 to April 2023. V.5553
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
16. Aug. 2024 EWN (EYEWITNESS NEWS )
Father unable to register his son because he is not the mother
For the past eight years, Mqokeleli Sigwintshi has been trying to get a birth certificate from the Department of Home Affairs for his son, who is now nine years old. Sigwintshi said in 2015, his wife, with whom he had a traditional marriage, gave birth to their son at the Willowvale Health Centre. A year later, his wife visited her family in Mthatha. V.5550
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
14. Aug. 2024 Reuters
People leave New Zealand in record numbers as economy bites
People are leaving New Zealand in record numbers as unemployment rises, interest rates remain high and economic growth is anaemic, government statistics show. Data released by Statistics New Zealand on Tuesday showed that 131 200 people departed New Zealand in the year ended June 2024, provisionally the highest on record for an annual period. Around a third of these were headed to Australia. While net migration, the number of those arriving minus those leaving, remains at high levels, economists also expect this to wane as the number of foreign nationals wanting to move to New Zealand falls due to the softer economy. The data showed of those departing 80 174 were citizens, which was almost double the numbers seen leaving prior to the Covid-19 pandemic. V.5548
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
14. Aug. 2024 SABC3
De Lille calls for concerted efforts for tourism to grow SA economy
Tourism Minister Patricia de Lille has called for concerted efforts to ensure that the potential of the tourism sector to grow the economy is realised. The sector is one of the apex contributors to the economy. The country is seeking to attract 15 million tourists to South Africa by 2030 as the National Development Plan envisages. V.5549
Click here for full article
Deprecated: Function strftime() is deprecated in /home/samiglpg/public_html/article_full_V01.php on line 324
13. Aug. 2024 Zimoja News
Driven by a desire for a luxurious lifestyle
A Congolese national was sentenced to 12 years for corruption and other crimes. CRIMINAL SYNDICATES Congolese national Tiny Mtumba (36) was sentenced to 12 years and 3 months imprisonment for fraud, theft, and contravention of the Immigration Act by the Palm Ridge Commercial Court in the East Rand in Gauteng on Thursday. V.5547
